Who stands in the way of a strong Somali State?
What happened
Single source · Caasimada Online
The article discusses the challenges facing Somalia in becoming a strong state, including historical events and foreign influences that have hindered its development.
What else the report says
- Decision reportedAfter Siad Barre was involved in a car accident in 1986, power passed into the hands of his family.
- What happens nextWhat will the Somali government do about these?
- Who is affectedAfter civilians fled those regions, the government began to lose its grip on the country.
- I am sure these questions weigh on the minds of many Somalis.
- Still unclear
- What specific evidence supports the claims about foreign involvement in Somalia's conflicts?

More from this report
Key points
The article discusses the challenges facing Somalia in becoming a strong state, including historical events and foreign influences that have hindered its development.
Original report with a saved translation · English
English · Machine translated · Not human reviewed
Original source text
What has gone wrong in Somalia? Do we know what is holding us back, and who wants to prevent Somalia from becoming a strong state that develops its natural resources, builds its armed forces, and takes its place among the African nations striving for progress?
I am sure these questions weigh on the minds of many Somalis. Yet many still do not know why the country has reached this point. To understand how we got here, we must look back at our history and the events that brought us here.
Since gaining independence on July 1, 1960, Somalia was among the few countries at the forefront of defending the rights of the Palestinian people. We stood with our Palestinian brothers and sisters through our politics, our faith, and our poetry.
The late President Mohamed Siad Barre, may Allah have mercy on him, was among the world leaders who openly condemned Israel’s abuses against the Palestinian people. That part of the story is familiar to many.
What happened next? I argue that Somalia was the first country where the West and Israel pursued what is now called regime change. In my account, the first attempt came in 1979, when Israeli intelligence organized a failed coup.
I contend that Israeli intelligence then began training and arming clan-based rebel movements. Officers from the Somali National Movement and the Somali Salvation Democratic Front were the first to be taken to Israel for training. Western intelligence services, particularly those of the United States and Italy, financed the United Somali Congress.
After Siad Barre was involved in a car accident in 1986, power passed into the hands of his family. The clan-based rebel movements took advantage of that opening and stepped up their activities. Barre’s government mounted its first counteroffensive in the northern regions in 1988. After civilians fled those regions, the government began to lose its grip on the country.
In my view, Israel helped accelerate the rebel advance as the movements took control of parts of the country. The fighting reached Mogadishu on December 31, 1990, marking the beginning of the collapse of the central government.
What followed the collapse?
Somalia was unprepared for Siad Barre’s overthrow. The movements that had fought his government turned on one another, and the fighting followed clan lines. Some elders worked hard to preserve what remained of the state. Once their efforts became known, some of them were massacred in a house where they had gathered.
What followed was a clan war that, in my view, the West and Israel financed to keep Somalia in a state of permanent conflict and prevent a strong government from emerging.
As clan fighting subsided and the country fragmented, foreign funding shifted toward the leaders involved in forming Kenya’s 2004 elected government. I see Ethiopia as having acted on behalf of the West and Israel in that process. On October 10, 2004, Abdullahi Yusuf, a former SSDF officer, was elected president.
At the same time, warlords in Mogadishu received funding and continued to sow disorder until 2006.
That year, I argue, foreign funding reached the Islamic Courts, which took control of Mogadishu and the two Shabelle regions. The main objective was to pave the way for Ethiopia to send a large military force into Somalia. In my account, Western countries backed both Ethiopia and the Islamic Courts while providing cover for Israel.
The Islamic Courts gained more support than their backers had expected. Somalis showed that they preferred governance based on Islam to rule along clan lines. I argue that the United States then split the Courts in two after reaching an agreement with their senior leaders. One faction entered government through the election in Djibouti with a bloc of 250 members of parliament. The other became the terrorist group Al-Shabaab.
I am convinced that Western policy has been to keep Somalia in a permanent state of war by supporting both the Somali government and Al-Shabaab.
Türkiye’s role in Somalia’s recovery
In 2011, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, then Türkiye’s prime minister and now its president, took the initiative to bring Somalia back to the world’s attention. Regular humanitarian assistance followed. Türkiye helped build roads and hospitals and develop the port and airport. It offered scholarships to Somali students, and thousands of young Somalis educated in Türkiye now work in Somalia.
The partnership also extended to training and equipping a capable Somali military and helping Somalia develop its oil and other natural resources.
As Somalia began to recover, I argue that Israel, this time acting through the United Arab Emirates, launched a campaign against Türkiye and began directly supporting the Somali opposition. I also believe efforts were made to revive clan warfare, beginning in Hiiraan and South West State.
In my view, the UAE and Israel drew in some of the countries that contributed troops to the African Union Support and Stabilisation Mission in Somalia, known as AUSSOM. I contend that some of those troops, particularly Ethiopian forces, fought alongside Al-Shabaab. I see that as the first evidence of Israeli financing on both sides.
I argue that Israel, with US support, brought about regime change in Iraq, Syria, Iran, and Libya but failed in Iran, Somalia, and Sudan. In the diplomatic contest between Israel and Türkiye, I believe Türkiye has prevailed in Libya, Sudan, and Syria. I am convinced it will prevail in Somalia as well.
My concerns also extend to the current Somali government. I believe Israel has people inside the government, particularly in the security and financial institutions. I also believe it has business contacts in Mogadishu who own hotels and companies operating within the Halane compound.
What will the Somali government do about these? I leave it to the government to investigate and respond.
Prof. Isse Sheikh Ali, lecturer at Somali National University.
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author(s) and do not necessarily represent the official stance of Caasimada Online or its members.
Context and open questions
Reader briefing
Article context
What happened
- The article discusses the challenges facing Somalia in becoming a strong state, including historical events and foreign influences that have hindered its development. It reflects on Somalia's past, particularly its independence and subsequent conflicts, suggesting that external forces have played a role in its struggles.
Source limitations
- The article presents a subjective analysis without independent verification of the claims made.
- It lacks direct quotes from officials or experts to support its assertions.
- No opposing viewpoints or responses from relevant parties are included.
Reader takeaway
The article highlights the complex historical and external factors that have contributed to Somalia's current challenges.
What remains unclear
- What specific evidence supports the claims about foreign involvement in Somalia's conflicts?
- How do current Somali leaders view the historical narrative presented in the article?
- What are the implications of these claims for Somalia's future governance and stability?
Why it matters
The article does not provide enough independently verified detail to assess the specific significance of this event beyond what is reported.
Follow Warkasta on WhatsApp
Follow our channel for the latest news.
Follow the channel →Why this story appears
This is a single source report from Warkasta’s monitored network. The source link remains available so you can read the publisher’s original context.
- Source count
- 1
- Sources used
- Caasimada Online
- Language mix
- English
- Translation status
- Shown in its original language
- AI synthesis
- No AI synthesis is used for this story panel
Signals used: somalia · general · who · strong · state